Compare
Coinrule vs 3Commas
Side by side from sourced facts: pricing, markets, custody, incidents and each bot’s rule-based report card. We don’t pick a winner; what fits depends on how you trade.
| Coinrule | 3Commas | |
|---|---|---|
| Report card | Clear record No serious incident, regulator action or shutdown found in the sources we checked. Not an endorsement. | Caution At least one documented security incident, regulator action (non-fraud) or unverified performance claim in the last 5 years. |
| Category | Cloud bot platforms | Cloud bot platforms |
| What it is | If-this-then-that rule builder for automated crypto and stock trades. | Cloud platform for DCA, grid and signal bots that connects to your exchange account. |
| Pricing | Investor $19.99/mo; Trader $49.99/mo; Pro $975/mo; Enterprise custom. Source: cloud.coinrule.com/pricing | Free plan (no live trading); Starter $20/mo ($15/mo billed annually); Pro $50/mo; Expert $140/mo. Source: 3commas.io/pricing |
| Markets / exchanges | Binance, Binance.US, Coinbase, Kraken, Gate, Upbit, Hyperliquid, KuCoin, Trading 212, 30+ total Source: cloud.coinrule.com/docs/billing/plans-overview | Binance, Hyperliquid, Bybit, OKX, Bitget, Gate, Kraken, KuCoin, Coinbase Source: 3commas.io/exchanges |
| Your money | Connects to your exchange or broker with API keys; funds stay in your account there. | Connects to your exchange or broker with API keys; funds stay in your account there. |
| Code / license | Proprietary | Proprietary |
| Facts on record | None found in public sources. | Dec 28, 2022: an anonymous account leaked a database of roughly 100,000 exchange API keys; 3Commas confirmed the data came from its systems. Source: 3commas.io/blog/notice-on-api-data-disclosure-incident CoinDesk reported the FBI was investigating the breach. Source: coindesk.com/business/2022/12/29/fbi-investigating-3commas-data-breach |
| Official site | coinrule.com | 3commas.io |
Facts checked Oct 15, 2026. Report cards follow published rules; payouts never change them. Not investment advice.